Hong Kong regulator increases scrutiny of unlicensed VASPs and OTC venues

Bhutan Quietly Mining Bitcoin Since $5,000The tiny nation of Bhutan continues to be full of surprises recently where crypto is concerned, with the latest report suggesting that the kingdom has been mining bitcoin for a number of years already.© Pexels/Pema GyamtshoAccording to a recent report in The Bhutanese, a Bhutan-based publication led by investigative journalist, Tenzing Lamsing, the landlocked nation had been mining bitcoin over the course of a “few years” already, in an effort to diversify its sovereign portfolio.Long-term investment strategyUjjwal Deep Dahal, CEO of Druk Holding and Investments (DHI), told the publication that the venture was part of a long-term investment strategy. DHI is the commercial arm of the Royal Government of Bhutan. It was formed pursuant to a Royal Charter in 2007 with the mandate of making investments on behalf of Bhutan while optimizing usage of resources.The mining activity had centered on Bitcoin although there was a small provision for Ethereum-based mining when Ethereum was a mineable proof-of-work (PoW)-based blockchain network. It’s unclear of the precise timeline but the report outlines that DHI has engaged in the mining space over a number of years, and at a time in which the Bitcoin unit price was as low as $5,000.Exploiting cheap hydroNestled in the Himalayas, Bhutan has considerable hydroelectric resources. Bitcoin mining is ordinarily an expensive exercise but in scenarios where there are plentiful energy resources with a marginally cheaper cost of production than the average, it can be an attractive and profitable enterprise. Dahal outlined that these conditions enabled DHI to reinvest profits back into additional mining equipment.The precise time-frame of DHIs entry into Bitcoin mining is open to speculation. However, we do know that the Bitcoin unit price was last below $5,000 at the onset of the pandemic in March 2020. Prior to that, Bitcoin had risen above $5,000 in April 2019 following an acute bear market in 2018.Crypto lender entanglementsBhutan and DHI hit the crypto radar last month when it was revealed that the kingdom had made significant investments into and out of failed crypto lenders Celsius and BlockFi. Dahal has said that the royal charter-mandated firm had taken out loans with both crypto lenders and had fully repaid those loans. However, that may have been something that happened later than anticipated. The Bhutanese company had a $30 million loan from BlockFi. BlockFi liquidated the Bitcoin collateral associated with that loan in 2022 but it left a shortfall of $800,000. The failed lender subsequently sued DHI. As of an April 13 court filing, BlockFi submitted a voluntary dismissal of the lawsuit to the courts, presumably because the shortfall was subsequently paid by DHI.In the case of Celsius, DHI had withdrawn $65 million from the lending platform prior to it declaring bankruptcy. Consequently, the matter has been the subject of speculation relative to the potential for the Celsius bankruptcy estate to pursue DHI for a clawback of the withdrawn funds.

While the Web3 sector seemed to be hamstrung by litigation and regulatory scrutiny in 2023 following multiple platform failures, it's going out with a bang in China with news of a $10 billion fund in Shenzhen to support Web3 startups.Photo by 李大毛 没有猫 on UnsplashFueling Web3 startup growthGBA Capital, a Chinese venture capital (VC) firm, made a significant announcement during the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area Digital Economy Development Conference on Tuesday. The firm, backed by China's state-owned National Engineering Laboratory, unveiled plans to launch a substantial $10 billion Web3 fund. The conference also served as an educational platform, enlightening investors and attendees unfamiliar with the intricacies of the Web3 industry. Luo Jinhai, founder of Huoxun Finance and creator of the "Yuan Asset" concept, elucidated on the unique attributes of specific forms of digital assets, including independence, privacy, security, scarcity and liquidity. Metaverse focusThis initiative aims to fuel the growth of startups specializing in virtual reality, the metaverse and non-fungible tokens (NFTs), ultimately transforming the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao economic region into the global "meta-asset capital."  Meta-assets are virtual objects that serve as key components within the make-up of the metaverse. Haolong Li, the chairman of GBA Capital, outlined the ambitious vision, stating that the conference would facilitate "meta-asset global tours" in key international hubs such as Japan, Singapore, Dubai, Silicon Valley and Europe. The objective is to enhance the visibility of meta-assets and position the economic area as a leading force in the emerging Web3 landscape. Previous developments that have played out over the course of 2023 suggest that China is placing a particular focus on embracing metaverse technology, with a view towards integrating the metaverse with existing systems in the country.   The Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of China, in response to a proposal about promoting the development of the Web3 industry, emphasized ongoing research in areas such as the Metaverse, NFTs and decentralized identity management. In September the Ministry set out an action plan for the cultivation of a domestic metaverse. As part of that plan, it aspires to nurture three to five metaverse companies of global significance. GBA Capital, established by China Europe International Financial Group in Hong Kong, boasts strategic partnerships with key financial institutions, including the Asia Pacific Investment Bank and China's state-owned National Engineering Laboratory. The firm's focus on investment and incubation in the digital economy aligns with its goal of integrating industrial clusters, capital resources, corporate resources and policy advantages to offer comprehensive support and services to enterprises. In a related development, GBA Capital's subsidiary Zhongrong Global successfully raised an angel funding round at a valuation of 100 million Chinese yuan ($14 million) back in May. The funds will be allocated to Web3 project incubation and industrial services in the artificial intelligence sector. The Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Bay Area has experienced a surge in Web3 startups and overseas corporate relocations since the beginning of the year, setting the stage for GBA Capital's substantial Web3 accelerator fund.

Taiwan’s FSC to Release Cryptocurrency Guidelines for Banks in SeptemberHuang Tien-Mu, Chairman of the Taiwanese Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC), said at the Legislative Yuan that regulatory guidelines for banks concerning cryptocurrencies will be available in September, as reported by local blockchain media Blocktempo.© Pexels/ Timo VolzHuang’s remarks were in response to questions from Legislator Lee Guei-min about crypto-related issues.Legislator’s three concernsLee raised three concerns: the accessibility of DBS Digital Exchange, currently operating in Singapore, for Taiwanese users; whether traditional banks should be permitted to provide crypto trading platforms; and investor protection against exchange collapses like the one experienced by FTX.FSC Chairman’s answersHuang stated that the FSC has not received any requests related to DBS Digital Exchange. He mentioned the commission’s concerns about the intrinsic value of cryptocurrencies and their ongoing work on regulatory guidelines, set for release in September. Huang also highlighted the importance of financial authorities overseeing crypto trading platforms, citing FTX Japan as an example, where users are protected under Japanese regulations.To safeguard investors from potential collapses, Huang suggested separating assets between hot and cold wallets. Furthermore, he noted that the FSC is not considering allowing the 27 crypto trading platforms registered with the commission to be listed on Taiwanese stock exchanges.