Top

Korea considers legal recognition of virtual assets as trust assets for investor protection

Policy & Regulation·November 28, 2023, 9:11 AM

South Korea’s Ministry of Justice (MOJ) is assessing whether customers’ virtual assets on cryptocurrency exchanges should be legally recognized as trust assets. This classification would give users priority in claiming their virtual assets in case of an exchange’s bankruptcy, thus strengthening investor protection. There’s a noted concern about potential disputes in such bankruptcy situations, as users’ digital assets are typically considered to be in the custody or storage of these platforms.

Photo by Daniel Bernard on Unsplash

 

Legal study by Seoul National University

According to a Tuesday report by local news outlet ChosunBiz, citing industry and legal sources, the MOJ has initiated a legal study on this subject. The research is being conducted by the Seoul National University R&DB Foundation, which started the project earlier this month.

Through this study, the MOJ is expected to examine the legal classification of cryptocurrency as property. This review is significant because, for cryptocurrencies to be held in a trust, they must be legally recognized as property. Meanwhile, the upcoming Virtual Asset User Protection Act, set to come into effect next July, mandates that only cash deposits made by users be segregated from the assets of the exchange itself.

In Korea, under the current provisions of the Capital Markets Act, virtual assets are not recognized as being held in a trust. Instead, staked cryptocurrencies are seen as being under custodial management or storage. In such arrangements, only a debtor-creditor relationship concerning virtual assets is acknowledged, differing from the legal framework of a trust.

 

Prioritization of rights

If a cryptocurrency exchange becomes insolvent and enters liquidation, the current legal framework could end up prioritizing the rights of the exchange’s creditors or shareholders over those of the crypto investors. This situation has faced criticism for its inadequate protection of investors. However, if the crypto assets were considered to be held in trusts, it would enable users to acquire “rights to foreclose outside bankruptcy.” This means users would have the right to receive priority reimbursement for their crypto assets, offering them a higher level of protection in the event of an exchange’s bankruptcy.

Regarding this development, an official from the MOJ said that while the study is a fundamental legal review focused on exploring ways to protect users through the application of trusts for various cryptocurrency transactions, including those involving decentralized finance (DeFi), it is too early to provide specific details at this stage.

More to Read
View All
Web3 & Enterprise·

Oct 15, 2024

OKX launches in UAE with full operating license

Global crypto exchange OKX has acquired full licensing in the United Arab Emirates and with that, it has launched its trading platform in the Gulf state. Serving retail and institutional clientsThat’s according to a press release published by PR Newswire on the company’s behalf on Oct. 10. The platform has now been opened to both retail and institutional investors in the UAE. Those customers who have completed the required onboarding steps, either via the OKX app or the OKX website, can now access the firm’s range of services. Those services include spot trading, on-chain yield-bearing products, token conversion and express buy and sell services. For retail-level customers to qualify for derivatives trading, they are obliged to undergo a knowledge test in addition to undertaking a suitability assessment.  When it comes to institutional clients, the platform has advised that they will have access to derivatives trading so long as they have met specific criteria set out by the company. It’s understood that this will include specific "Know Your Customer" requirements set out by OKX. Photo by Phil Shaw on UnsplashMinimum liquidity requirementsAdditionally, an institutional investor must meet two out of three minimum liquidity requirements. These are understood to include a net annual turnover of $40 million, the institution’s own funds being in excess of $2 million or a balance sheet demonstrating a minimum of $20 million. Investors will be able to deposit or withdraw UAE dirhams (AED) to/from the OKX platform, with AED trading pairs having been established for a range of cryptocurrencies including Bitcoin, Tether and Ether. Launch eventAside from the company’s press release, OKX made its announcement at an event at the Museum of the Future at an event which it titled “A New Alternative for Dubai.” The event featured OKX CEO Star Xu, the firm’s CMO Haider Rafique, SkyBridge Capital’s Anthony Scaramucci, Polygon Co-Founder Sandeep Nailwal and Stacks Co-Founder Muneeb Ali.  Scaramucci spoke positively about the business conditions that have been created in the UAE, stating that the change “in 20 years is nothing short of a miracle.” With that, he recognized that’s why OKX has established itself within the UAE. OKX General Manager for the Middle East and North Africa (MENA), Rifad Mahasneh, told Cointelegraph that the company is “extremely bullish on the UAE as a crypto hub and only see the sector growing in the next few years.” Mahasneh told CoinDesk that the firm has two targets in the UAE, with its intention to onboard retail clients via the OKX app and lure TradFi institutions. "The return on investment is going to come from our ability to convert traditional institutions,” he stated. OKX has been working towards this moment for some time. It opened an office in Dubai in mid-2023, quickly expanding its presence by hiring local staff. Its local subsidiary, OKX Middle East Fintech FZE, received a non-operational license from Dubai’s Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority (VARA) in January of this year.

news
Web3 & Enterprise·

Jan 22, 2024

FSN and Fingo join hands to pursue tokenized securities business

South Korean digital marketing firm FSN has entered into a strategic alliance with Fingo Company, the operator of the music copyright platform Fingo, to jointly work on a tokenized securities project based on the recently raised funds, according to local news site Newsis on Monday (KST).Photo by Chris Liverani on UnsplashUnlocking synergiesThrough this partnership, FSN and Fingo aim to collaborate on a token securities project. As both companies have experience in leveraging IP, they are expected to apply their expertise to the new business. In particular, FSN operates several IP-based Web3 projects such as Sunmiya Club and Bellygom NFT through its subsidiary Finger Labs, through which the firm has been demonstrating its competitive edge. Fingo also owns a variety of content-based IPs and is cooperating with major domestic securities companies. The two firms’ business capabilities are thus expected to create great synergy in the market. Fingo’s service allows anyone to share revenue made from music, a concept referred to as music revenue sharing, which was once limited to creators or singers only. Last year, it took a step into the tokenized securities sphere by signing a business deal with Mirae Asset Securities, the country’s largest asset manager, to establish a token securities service and launch innovative financial investment products. FSN has been gearing up to take on this collaborative project, namely a recent success in raising a total of KRW 10 billion (approximately $7.5 million) in funding. The company explained that with this considerable funding paired with its knowledge of Web3 and blockchain technology and experience in collaborative partnerships, it will be equipped to settle into the tokenized securities market seamlessly. Charting new horizons"As we have secured large-scale funding under stable conditions, we expect to successfully pursue new businesses, including that in tokenized securities," FSN CEO Lee Sang-seok said. "We will steadily expand new businesses by establishing partnerships with companies with competitiveness in various areas, starting with Fingo Company, which has a competitive edge in tokenized securities and music IP," he said.

news
Policy & Regulation·

May 19, 2023

BOK Staffers Assess Crypto Market Vulnerabilities and Their Implications

BOK Staffers Assess Crypto Market Vulnerabilities and Their ImplicationsOn Thursday, the Bank of Korea’s (BOK) staff members published an assessment of the vulnerabilities in the cryptocurrency market and their potential implications. Here is the summary of the report.Photo by D Tan on Unsplash2022 crypto winterThroughout 2022, the worldwide crypto market faced a series of adverse occurrences, such as significant drops in the prices of major crypto-assets and the collapse of prominent crypto companies. These events shed light on the vulnerabilities that had accumulated during the rapid growth of the market.The first major event occurred in May 2022 when the algorithmic stablecoin TerraUSD experienced a sharp decline, resulting in substantial losses and bankruptcies for numerous retail investors and crypto firms. This incident significantly eroded confidence in the overall crypto market. The subsequent bankruptcies of prominent crypto lender Celsius and hedge fund Three Arrows Capital (3AC) further highlighted the realization of risks commonly associated with traditional financial markets, such as multiple collateral loans and maturity and liquidity mismatches, within the crypto market.In November 2022, the well-known crypto exchange FTX filed for bankruptcy, demonstrating that the activities of a large crypto company can propagate risks through moral hazard and excessive profit-seeking behavior when it operates outside the realm of regulatory oversight.Similarities with TradFiThese negative events that unfolded in the global crypto market in 2022 share similarities with issues previously observed in financial markets, such as unsustainable business models, liquidity risk, leverage, and lack of transparency in financial conditions. These parallels suggest that if the crypto markets were subjected to comparable levels of regulation as traditional financial markets, it is plausible that the triggering of these risks could have been avoided altogether, or at the very least, the resulting damage could have been mitigated to some extent.Implications for the Korean marketAt present, it is deemed unlikely that events akin to those witnessed in overseas crypto markets will transpire in the Korean market. The Korean crypto-asset market has primarily evolved through exchanges, with limited influence from other enterprises such as crypto issuers and decentralized lending platforms. In addition, Korean crypto exchanges are subject to regulation under the Act on Reporting and Using Specified Financial Transaction Information. This mandates the separation of customer deposits from exchange assets and the strict management of custodial crypto-assets through secure wallets. Additionally, Korean exchanges are prohibited from listing their own tokens on their platforms.However, there remains a dearth of information regarding the business structures of crypto companies that offer services similar to those in the traditional financial industry. This lack of information poses challenges in accurately assessing risk and providing adequate investor protection. Meanwhile, there is a potential for a deeper integration between the crypto market and users’ daily lives, particularly through major technology companies, gaming companies, and security tokens.SuggestionsIt is vital to ensure that crypto-assets are regulated based on the principle of “same activity, same risk, same regulation” through the ongoing development of crypto-asset-related legislation. The Financial Stability Board, an international body monitoring the global financial system, explained this principle in a 2022 paper: “Where crypto-assets and intermediaries perform an equivalent economic function to one performed by instruments and intermediaries of the traditional financial sector, they should be subject to equivalent regulation.”Additionally, it is necessary to stay aligned with major countries in terms of the speed and comprehensiveness of regulatory measures to prevent regulatory discrepancies across borders due to the global nature of crypto risks.Enhancing the effectiveness and efficiency of regulation requires the establishment and maintenance of a close cooperation system between authorities. This collaborative effort should encompass various aspects, including monitoring, information gathering, and supervision of the crypto-asset market. Notably, the widespread adoption of stablecoins can affect the stability of the overall financial system, including monetary systems and payment and settlement systems. Hence, it is necessary to strengthen the involvement of central banks in the monitoring and supervision framework for crypto-assets, including stablecoins, as demonstrated by legislative approaches adopted by major economies like the EU. Furthermore, imposing disclosure requirements, external audits, and documentation submission obligations on crypto-asset operators is advisable.

news
Loading