Hong Kong SFC CEO Prioritizes Investor Protection in Crypto Regulations

BitMEX CEO Calls for an End to Internal Market MakersIn a recent interview, Stephan Lutz, the acting CEO and group CFO of 100x Group, the parent company of Seychelles-headquartered global crypto exchange BitMEX, expressed his belief that crypto exchanges should phase out their internal market-making teams.Photo by Joe Roberts on UnsplashProp trading desks unnecessarySpeaking with The Block, Lutz argued that with the growth of institutional liquidity providers and high-frequency traders (HFTs) in the market, proprietary trading desks are becoming unnecessary.Lutz stated: “You have enough HFTs out there and prop shops that can perform that function.” He was referring to the role of liquidity providers in filling gaps in the market. He made these comments in response to the emergence of information earlier this week that raised questions about internal trading practices at Crypto.com, a Singapore-based exchange.BitMEX, once the world’s largest crypto derivatives exchange, also used to employ internal traders who acted as market makers. However, Lutz explained that BitMEX’s internal trading team, named Arrakis Capital, now functions primarily as a “treasury desk.” He sees this transition as a natural evolution for crypto exchanges in a market that has matured and attracted more institutional liquidity providers.Arrakis Capital currently performs limited functions, including converting commission fees earned in Bitcoin into fiat currency for operational purposes, hedging BitMEX’s exposure to tokens held as inventory, and making markets for BitMEX’s token $BMEX. Lutz clarified that Arrakis’s market-making activities are limited because external market makers find the token’s liquidity insufficient.Regarding profitability, Lutz stated that Arrakis earns “very minor returns” of up to $100,000 per month from holding T-Bills, but it incurred losses last year. He noted that Arrakis used to play a more significant market-making role when BitMEX dominated the crypto futures market. However, he assured that the trading desk was always segregated, despite accusations in the past.Fee structuresLutz acknowledged that exchanges with internal trading teams have faced increased scrutiny since the controversies surrounding Alameda Research and FTX. To differentiate between benign internal trading teams and hedge fund-like operations, Lutz highlighted several factors, including the separation of client funds and house funds, access to sensitive data, and the ability to move markets on their own exchange. Fee structures also play a role, with low or no transaction fees potentially signaling a market-making motive rather than serving as a counterparty.Lutz’s perspective suggests that crypto exchanges should rely on external liquidity providers and HFTs rather than maintaining internal market-making teams. He argues that the market has evolved. At this point he feels that these teams are no longer necessary, due to the presence of established players within the digital assets space.As regulatory scrutiny grows, ensuring transparency and avoiding conflicts of interest become crucial for maintaining trust within the crypto exchange ecosystem. The digital assets industry is far from arriving at a mature stage in its development. While many in the industry have found the stance taken by regulators to be unhelpful, the industry itself must also demonstrate its ability to iteratively move towards best practice, without that being a knee-jerk response to regulatory enforcement.

Starbucks Korea implements NFT initiative to boost sustainability effortsStarbucks Korea is set to take on several eco-friendly initiatives in the new year to promote the use of personal reusable cups, including an NFT wallet and a new tumbler coupon policy, according to local news outlet Newsis on Thursday (KST).Photo by Battlecreek Coffee Roasters on UnsplashNFTs and eco-friendly effortsIn a newfound development, the brand also said that it would start issuing NFTs through a new NFT wallet on its mobile app next month as part of its eco-friendly consumption campaign. Until now, NFTs have been widely utilized in fields like art, music and entertainment due to their ability to prove individual ownership of digital assets. Starbucks’ adoption of the technology is a significant step in its implementation into daily life, which will lead to an increase in the number of real-world use cases and an acceleration in the transition to the era of Web3.To celebrate the launch of the NFT wallet, Starbucks plans to hold a promotional event where customers who use a reusable cup for one beverage ordered via the Siren Order function will receive one Eco Stamp. Up to three stamps can be collected per day. These can be exchanged for various types of NFTs, which are categorized as Basic, Creative and Artist, and each customer can only own one.Starbucks’ NFTs will be minted in collaboration with Seoul-based art platform and gallery Print Bakery (PBG) and PBG exclusive artist DADAZ, featuring images of unique cups, tumblers and more.The franchise plans to hold an offline exhibition to showcase images of the NFTs as well as its achievements in corporate sustainability at the Starbucks Jongno R store located in Jongno-gu, central Seoul, early next month.Sustainable sipsThe coffee franchise is also known for offering a complimentary beverage voucher to customers who purchase a reusable cup or tumbler. Next month, this voucher will be renamed the Eco Tumbler Beverage Coupon, which customers can exchange for a tall-sized beverage of their choice. This policy is aimed at encouraging the use of personal cups and providing tailored benefits to customers who embrace sustainable options.This new introduction was partially driven by the steady increase in the number of personal cups used at Starbucks stores around the country over the past three years. The annual number of cases has risen from 17.39 million in 2020 to 21.9 million in 2021, then 25.3 million last year.This figure has spiked significantly this year in particular, with the cumulative yearly number reaching 26.7 million last month, surpassing last year’s total. If this trend continues until the end of the year, the estimated figure is expected to be around 29.6 million, representing a 17% increase compared to 2022.This upward trend is attributed to the immediate KRW 400 discount offered to customers who participate, as well as an alternative benefit where customers can earn one “Star”, or reward point, for each purchase that they make. Until last month, the total value of benefits that were distributed via these two systems — with one Star valued at KRW 500 — exceeded KRW 12 billion. The ratio of immediate discount and Star rewards in this value stands at 30% and 70%, respectively.Green commitmentStarbucks also plans to continue its No Single-Use Cup Day campaign, a collaboration with the Korea Zero Waste Movement Network that has been ongoing for the past five years. The brand dedicates the tenth of every month as a day without single-use disposable cups, giving out merchandise like mugs, tumblers, coffee ground planting kits and stickers. Since last year, various events have been organized to celebrate the day, such as coupons gifted to customers who use reusable cups the most. Approximately one million people have participated in these promotions since the campaign’s inception in 2018.Starbucks expressed its hopes that these initiatives would act as a catalyst for positive changes in local communities by encouraging the reduction of waste.

Singapore Gets with Banks to Provide Guidance on Crypto BusinessesIn a move to provide clarity and guidance to financial institutions dealing with cryptocurrencies, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) is reportedly working with banks to develop new vetting procedures for crypto clients.According to a recent Bloomberg report, the MAS plans to provide more detailed guidance to banks on how to properly screen and monitor customers involved in cryptocurrency transactions.©Pexels/PixabayRegulatory clarityThe decision to provide guidance on crypto businesses comes as regulators around the world struggle to keep up with the rapidly-evolving digital currency industry. Many governments have been grappling with how to regulate cryptocurrencies in the face of concerns over money laundering, fraud, and other illicit activities.Singapore, however, has taken a more progressive stance on digital currencies, with the MAS recently announcing plans to create a regulatory framework for crypto derivatives trading. The country’s financial watchdog has also been working to improve AML (anti-money laundering) and CFT (combating the financing of terrorism) measures relative to crypto transactions.The MAS’s efforts to provide guidance to banks on crypto businesses are part of this broader push to promote responsible use of digital currencies in Singapore. By providing clear and detailed guidance to financial institutions, the regulator hopes to prevent illegal activities from taking place while also promoting the growth of the crypto industry.The MAS’s approach is seen as a positive development for the crypto industry, as it provides a clear framework for financial institutions to work within. This could help to boost confidence in the crypto market, potentially leading to increased investment and adoption.Striking the right balanceAt the same time, however, some industry observers have expressed concerns that overly strict regulations could stifle innovation and limit the potential of cryptocurrencies. They argue that a balance must be struck between protecting consumers and promoting innovation in the digital currency industry.Despite these concerns, the MAS’s efforts to provide guidance on crypto businesses are likely to be welcomed by financial institutions and industry participants alike. As the use of digital currencies continues to grow, it is becoming increasingly important for regulators to provide clear and comprehensive guidance on how to operate within this rapidly-evolving industry.Previous failuresSingapore hasn’t always gotten its approach to cryptocurrency right. In 2021, the MAS put global crypto exchange Binance on its investor alert list. Binance felt compelled to curb its service offering in the city state. The consequence of that action was that a disproportionate number of Singaporeans proceeded to open accounts with FTX only later to get caught up in the collapse of the exchange.The Monetary Authority of Singapore’s decision to provide guidance on crypto businesses is bullish for the digital currency industry. By providing clear and detailed guidance to financial institutions, the regulator is promoting responsible use of cryptocurrencies in Singapore while also boosting confidence in the market. However, there is a need to strike a balance between protecting consumers and promoting innovation in the industry, as overly strict regulations could stifle growth and limit the potential of cryptocurrencies.